Re: 9/10/11 event
Reply #14 - August 26, 2011, 03:52 PM
There is always going to be a certain degree of insularity in immigrant minority groups, especially recent emigrants.
All minorities have to guard against over-insularity because excessive insularity ultimately harms them most of all.
A certain amount of insularity is not a bad thing - if it comes from a culture of getting your head down and working hard so your children can do well, that is just the process of integration and acculturation.
But its a balance that does have to be observed from both sides.
The question comes when some ideologies tend to actively promote insularity and disdain for wider society. In the UK, Deobandi / Jamaati / Salafi / Tableegi Islam have done great damage to Muslims themselves by promoting insularity and suspicion and hostility towards non Muslims and wider society, especially in already stratified parts of the country like the northern cities and towns.
I don't know if that applies in America because I don't know enough, but I do know that this kind of Islamic theology or attitude is divisive and reactionary.
So a certain degree of inwardness is not unhealthy per se (look how Chinese immigrants follow a pattern of insular hard working first generation followed by high achieving second generation who enter the middle class through high academic / professional attainment), but when there are hostile barriers to integration, whether religious, cultural or identity-politics wise, that alter this trajectory, then it becomes a problem.
"we can smell traitors and country haters"
God is Love.
Love is Blind. Stevie Wonder is blind. Therefore, Stevie Wonder is God.