Welcome Asiya. I went to an Islamic College where I witnessed many non-Muslim teachers converting to Islam.
I only know one that remained Muslim, and I still see her occasionally.
When the other teachers converted, we had multiple Friday sermons about how they found the great Islam, and they told stories about how they felt Allah and cried in their prayers and so on.
There was a strong community emphasis on their conversions, so all eyes were on them. As a community, we were told to invite them and include them in anyway we could.
In the end, a few secretly became apostates, deleted all their internet profiles and moved to different states.
Good luck and welcome